This is the first time we have produced a review of employment law cases from the previous year, based on analysis by various of our academic board members. But before looking at their findings, we would first like to make some general remarks. |


European Employment Law Cases
About this journalSubscribe to the email alerts for this journal here to receive notifications when a new issue is at your disposal.
Editorial |
|
Law Review |
|
Authors | Ruben Houweling, Catherine Barnard, Zef Even e.a. |
Abstract |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | General discrimination |
Authors | Kayleigh Williams |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The Court of Appeal has overruled the recent Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) decision in Efobi – v – Royal Mail [2017] IRLR 956 (reported in EELC 2017/41), restoring the previous position that a claimant in a discrimination case has the initial burden of proof – which ‘shifts’ to the respondent to provide an explanation of why its conduct was non-discriminatory if a prima facie case is proven. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Age discrimination |
Authors | Paul Schreiner and Jana Voigt |
AbstractAuthor's information |
An acquired mother tongue is – at least indirectly – connected to a person’s origin and therefore also linked to ethnic origin. Claims based on the German General Equal Treatment Act (Allgemeines Gleichbehandlungsgesetz, the ‘AGG’) must be brought in writing within two months after knowledge of a possible discrimination. Time only starts to run for claims after the employer has provided an unsuccessful job applicant with a clear and definite statement that he or she has been rejected. The limitation period under the AGG will not be triggered by lapse of time only. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Freedom of expression, Unfair dismissal |
Authors | Gautier Busschaert |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Racist ‘liking’ on Facebook may justify dismissal for serious misconduct, says the Labour Court of Liège in a decision of 24 March 2017. This case is interesting because, to the author’s knowledge, it is the first time that a simple ‘like’ (as opposed to a proper comment) on Facebook is assessed by a Belgian judge with a view to validate a dismissal for serious misconduct. This case also raises serious questions about the limits to the freedom of expression in social media. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Unfair dismissal, Privacy |
Authors | Paul Schreiner |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The German federal court for labour law matters, the Bundesarbeitsgericht (the ‘BAG’), has held that evidence cannot be used in a dismissal lawsuit if the employer has obtained it from long-term surveillance using keylogger-software. Employers must not keep their employees under constant surveillance and must therefore expect their legal position to be weak if they try to dismiss an employee based on findings from such monitoring. The court ruling preceded the ECtHR Barbulescu ruling of 5 September 2017 (featured in EELC 2017/4) in a similar case. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Dismissal/severance payment, Transfer of undertaking |
Authors | Gabriella Ormai |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The Hungarian Supreme Court has held that within the context of the transfer of an undertaking, the transferee can terminate employment relationships immediately after the transfer for operational reasons and can commence preparations to that effect before the transfer. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Private international law, Competency, Applicable law |
Authors | Amber Zwanenburg |
AbstractAuthor's information |
A Dutch first instance court applies the recent ECJ Ryanair ruling (C-168/16 and C-169/16) in another Ryanair private international law dispute. Even though the Dutch court accepted jurisdiction, it applied Irish law to the employees’ unfair termination claim. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Transfer of undertaking, Transfer |
Authors | Caterina Rucci and Alessandro De Giobbi |
AbstractAuthor's information |
A change of service provider may amount to the transfer of an undertaking. While this should not be surprising in itself, the authors discuss recent changes in Italian law in this case report. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Miscellaneous, Employment status |
Authors | Laetitia Cooke |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Following an appeal by Uber against an employment tribunal (ET) finding last year, which was featured in EELC 2017/10, that its drivers are ‘workers’ and not self-employed contractors (reported in EELC 2017-1), the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has now upheld the ET’s original decision. The EAT rejected Uber’s arguments that it was merely a technology platform, as well as its statement that it did not provide transportation services. This decision is important as it means that Uber drivers are entitled to certain rights under UK law, such as the right to holiday pay, to the national minimum wage (NMW) and protection against detrimental treatment for ‘blowing the whistle’ against malpractice. Uber has approximately 40,000 drivers (and about 3.5 million users of its mobile phone application in London alone) and so this decision has potentially significant financial consequences for the company. |
Case Reports |
|
Keywords | Miscellaneous |
Authors | Christian K. Clasen |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The Danish Supreme Court has ruled that the Danish authorities may have incurred liability by failing to act sufficiently quickly to amend the Danish Holiday Act to align it with EU law. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Working time and leave, Working time |
Abstract |
Regulation 561/2006 prohibits lorry drivers from taking their regular weekly rest periods in a vehicle. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Free movement, Social insurance |
Abstract |
A Member State to which workers have been posted may, in the case of fraud and under certain conditions, ask the courts to disregard an A1 certificate and apply its own social security legislation, including the recovery of contributions. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Age discrimination |
Abstract |
The non-discrimination principle and the freedom of occupation, as provided for in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, do not prevent the EU from setting an age limit for pilots involved in commercial air transport, provided that this is done in accordance with Article 52(1) of the Charter. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Maternity and parental leave, Discrimination, Gender discrimination |
Abstract |
Clause 5(1) and (2) of the revised Framework Agreement on parental leave precludes rules of national law which make promotion conditional on having successfully completed a probation, if probation has not taken place because of parental leave. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Free movement, Social insurance |
Abstract |
A Dutch employee who resides in Belgium and performs only 6.5% of his hours worked in Belgium (and the rest in the Netherlands), cannot be regarded as ‘normally’ pursuing an activity in two or more Member States. The special rule in Article 14(2)(b)(i) of Regulation No 1408/71, stating that a person normally employed in the territory of two or more Member States shall be subject to the legislation of the Member State in whose territory he resides, does not apply in this case. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Gender discrimination |
Abstract |
The competition notice for enrolment in Greek police schools requires applicants, whichever their gender, to be at least 1.70m in height. This disadvantages a far greater number of women than men and does not appear either appropriate or necessary to achieve the legitimate objective it pursues. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Transfer of undertaking, Transfer |
Abstract |
If a company terminates its contract with one business for the provision of security guard services at its facilities and then makes a new contract for the supply of the same services with another business – but that second business refuses to take on the employees of the first – the situation may be an transfer of an undertaking if the equipment essential to the performance of those services has been taken over by the second business. Further, under the Acquired Rights Directive Member States must ensure that if a business loses a service contract to another operator, this can be treated as a transfer. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | General discrimination, Gender discrimination |
Abstract |
The provisions on the burden of proof regarding the equal treatment of men and women in employment matters in Directive 2006/54 also apply to claims by breastfeeding workers based on Directive 92/85 (safety and health at work of pregnant workers and workers who have recently given birth or are breastfeeding). |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Miscellaneous |
Abstract |
Member States may not impose mandatory liquidation on companies that wish to transfer their registered office to another Member State. A restriction on freedom of establishment may be justified by overriding reasons in the public interest, such as the protection of the interests of creditors, minority shareholders and employees, but a general mandatory liquidation goes beyond what is necessary to achieve the objective of protecting these interests. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Part-time work |
Abstract |
While a provision that treats the unemployment benefits of vertical part-time workers unfavourably compared to full-time workers falls outside the scope of the Framework Agreement on part-time work, such a benefit scheme may still violate the principle of equal treatment of men and women, for example, if it is indirectly discriminatory towards women. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Working time |
Abstract |
The weekly rest period for workers laid down in Article 5 of Directive 2003/88 does not necessarily need to be granted on the day following six consecutive working days. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Paid leave |
Abstract |
The Working Time Directive precludes provisions that establish the right to be paid only after leave has been taken. Further, the right to paid leave (or a corresponding payment at the end of the employment relationship) cannot lapse if the employee has been deterred from taking the leave. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Free movement, Social insurance |
Abstract |
A minimum benefit as defined in Article 50 of Regulation No 1408/71 may not be calculated in accordance with Articles 46(2) and 47 of that Regulation, but benefits receive in other Member States may be taken into account in calculating the minimum benefit. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Free movement, Social insurance |
Abstract |
Self-employed workers who have ceased their activity for reasons beyond their control and who are registered as jobseekers, retain their status as self-employed persons for the purposes of Article 7(1)(a) of Directive 2004/38. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Employment status |
Abstract |
The overall degree of control which the Uber platform exercises over the workforce does not suggest that it acts merely as an intermediary. The services Uber provides fall within the field of transport within the meaning of EU law and not under the freedom to provide services. It is therefore for the Member States to regulate the conditions under which such services are to be provided in conformity with the general rules of the TFEU. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Fixed-term work, Other forms of discrimination |
Abstract |
A fixed-term worker elected to a parliamentary role must be able to benefit from the same special leave granted to a permanent civil servant, to enable them to hold a public office. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Unfair dismissal, Collective redundancies |
Abstract |
Directive 92/85 does not preclude national legislation that allows an employer to dismiss a pregnant worker in the context of a collective redundancy. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Working time |
Abstract |
The stand-by time of a volunteer firefighter at home who is obliged to respond to calls from his employer within eight minutes, must be regarded as ‘working time’. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Fixed-term work |
Abstract |
The Framework Agreement on fixed-term work and the Equal Treatment (Framework) Directive do not forbid a provision that allows parties to postpone the operation of a retirement age clause in employment periods for fixed time, even if this means that they can be extended infinitely. |
ECtHR Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Race, nationality discrimination |
Abstract |
Denial of military pension is deemed to be discriminatory based on nationality. |
ECtHR Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Fundamental rights, Privacy |
Abstract |
The Spanish courts breached Article 8 of the Convention on Human Rights by accepting covert footage as valid evidence in court. |
ECtHR Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Unfair dismissal, Other fundamental rights |
Abstract |
Dismissal for harassment despite acquittal in criminal proceedings is not incompatible with Article 6(2) of the Convention (presumption of innocence). |
ECtHR Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Unfair dismissal, Other fundamental rights |
Abstract |
The Turkish Supreme Administrative Court cast doubt on a dismissed police officer’s innocence by failing, in an appeal review, to take proper account of the fact that he had been acquitted of rape, in breach of the presumption of innocence contained in Article 6 §2 of the European Convention on Human Rights. |
ECtHR Court Watch |
|
Keywords | Unfair dismissal, Freedom of expression |
Abstract |
Dismissal after re-instatement of employment following an ECtHR judgment found an infringement of freedom of speech. |
ECJ Court Watch |
|
ECJ Court Watch |
|