Diversion is an important vehicle for delivering an alternative model of youth justice, one that is, hopefully, grounded in principles of children’s rights and restorative justice. Several Asia-Pacific countries, often with international assistance, have sought to develop alternative processes and programmes to which children in conflict with the law can be diverted to. In some instances, these have included restorative justice programmes. This article provides an overview of the implementation of a restorative justice approach, as a youth justice diversion measure, in four South-East Asian countries: Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines and Vietnam. It describes juvenile justice reforms in these countries, particularly as they relate to the implementation of diversion and restorative justice and reflects on the factors that may have affected the success of these reforms. Every one of these countries has achieved a measure of success in implementing diversion and restorative justice, although restorative justice has occupied a different place in these reforms. The article offers a general overview of key challenges and notable successes encountered during that process, as well as an opportunity to consider the role of tradition, culture and public expectations in the implementation of restorative justice principles in the context of juvenile justice. |
Search result: 1101 articles
Book Review |
Ted Lewis and Carl Stauffer, Listening to the movement |
Journal | The International Journal of Restorative Justice, Issue 1 2022 |
Authors | Thomas Levy |
Author's information |
Article |
Diversion and restorative justice in the context of juvenile justice reforms in Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines and Vietnam |
Journal | The International Journal of Restorative Justice, Issue Online First 2022 |
Keywords | children’s rights, juvenile justice, restorative justice, diversion, implementation challenges, Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia, the Philippines |
Authors | Le Thu Dao, Le Huynh Tan Duy, Ukrit Sornprohm e.a. |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Article |
Towards a restorative justice approach to white-collar crime and supra-individual victimisation |
Journal | The International Journal of Restorative Justice, Issue Online First 2022 |
Keywords | restorative justice, white-collar crimes, supra-individual victimisation, spokespersons at restorative meetings, eligibility criteria |
Authors | Daniela Gaddi and María José Rodríguez Puerta |
AbstractAuthor's information |
This work examines the feasibility of extending the implementation of restorative justice to the field of white-collar crime for a specific class of victimisation: that which people experience as a group (i.e. supra-individual victimisation). For this purpose, we analyse some key issues and outline a number of criteria for determining who would be able to speak on behalf of supra-individual victims of white-collar crime in restorative meetings. Some initial proposals are offered, based on four types of supra-individual victimisation, which would provide a framework for the selection of spokespersons who could attend restorative meetings in restoratively oriented criminal proceedings. |
Article |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2021 |
Keywords | SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, The state’s duty to protect, Duty to rescue, Responsibility, Solidarity |
Authors | Konstantinos A Papageorgiou |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The article discusses a range of important normative questions raised by anti-COVID-19 measures and policies. Do governments have the right to impose such severe restrictions on individual freedom and furthermore do citizens have obligations vis-à-vis the state, others and themselves to accept such restrictions? I will argue that a democratic state may legitimately enforce publicly discussed, properly enacted and constitutionally tested laws and policies in order to protect its citizens from risks to life and limb. Even so, there is a natural limit, factual and normative, to what the state or a government can do in this respect. Citizens will also need to take it upon themselves not to harm and to protect others and in the context of a pandemic this means that endorsement of restrictions or other mandatory measures, notably vaccination, is not to be seen as a matter of personal preference concerning the supposedly inviolable sovereignty of one’s own body. |
Article |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2021 |
Keywords | Vulnerability, Contingency, Freedom and Anxiety, Solidarity, Legal concept of inclusion |
Authors | Benno Zabel |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The COVID-19 crisis has produced or amplified disruptive processes in societies. This article wants to argue for the fact that we understand the meaning of the COVID-19 crisis only if we relate it to the fundamental vulnerability of modern life and the awareness of vulnerability of whole societies. Vulnerability in modernity are expressions of a reality of freedom that is to some extent considered contingent and therefore unsecured. It is true that law is understood today as the protective power of freedom. The thesis of the article, however, boils down to the fact that the COVID-19 crisis has resulted in a new way of thinking about the protection of freedom. This also means that the principle of solidarity must be assigned a new social role. Individual and societal vulnerability refer thereafter to an interconnectedness, dependency, and a future perspective of freedom margins that, in addition to the moral one, can also indicate a need for legal protection. In this respect, law has not only a function of delimitation, but also one of inclusion. |
Article |
|
Journal | East European Yearbook on Human Rights, Issue 1 2021 |
Authors | Martin Fertmann and Matthias C. Kettemann |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Terms-of-service based actions against political and state actors as both key subjects and objects of political opinion formation have become a focal point of the ongoing debates over who should set and enforce the rules for speech on online platforms. |
Article |
Legal Tradition and Human RightsA Quantitative Comparative Analysis of Developing Countries |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 3 2021 |
Keywords | comparative law, comparative constitutional analysis, human rights, legal traditions, quantitative constitutional analysis, economic rights, social and family rights, civil and political rights |
Authors | Dhanraj R. Singh |
AbstractAuthor's information |
This analysis examines the relationship between legal tradition and constitutional human rights. It experiments with a quantitative comparative methodology to compare economic rights, social and family rights, and civil and political rights between countries with common law, civil law and mixed law legal traditions. The results show that developing countries with a civil law legal tradition provide more constitutional human rights than their counterparts with a common law legal tradition. Although preliminary and imperfect, the results challenge the notion of superiority of the common law legal tradition and human rights. The quantitative comparative framework used offers a new methodological frontier for comparative constitutional law researchers to examine relationships between legal traditions. |
Developments in International Law |
The Decision on the Situation in Palestine Issued by Pre-Trial Chamber I of the International Criminal CourtReflecting on the Legal Merits |
Journal | Hungarian Yearbook of International Law and European Law, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | International Criminal Court, ICC, Palestine, Oslo Accords, jurisdiction |
Authors | Rachel Sweers |
AbstractAuthor's information |
On 5 February 2021, the Pre-Trial Chamber I of the International Criminal Court (ICC) issued its decision on the Situation in Palestine affirming that its territorial jurisdiction extends to the territories occupied by Israel since 1967, namely Gaza and the West Bank, including East Jerusalem. The Situation was brought before the Chamber by request of the ICC’s Prosecutor. Legal issues were addressed in the Majority Decision, as well as in the Partly Dissenting Opinion and Partly Separate Opinion. The procedural history involving the Prosecution Request that seized the Chamber on the Situation in Palestine will be discussed, including a brief analysis of the legal basis for this request. Furthermore, the legal merits of the Situation in Palestine will be compartmentalized into three main pillars in order to analyze step by step how the Chamber reached its conclusion. |
Public Health Emergency: National, European and International Law Responses |
Constitutional Rights in the Time of PandemicThe Experience of Hungary |
Journal | Hungarian Yearbook of International Law and European Law, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | state of emergency, emergency powers, restriction of fundamental rights, Fundamental Law, Constitutional Court of Hungary |
Authors | Lóránt Csink |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Special circumstances may require special measures. This article is to highlight the importance of constitutional rights, also in the time of a pandemic. Its hypothesis is that constitutional rights are not luxuries one can only afford in peacetime, they are much rather at the core of civilization and democracy. History shows that a world without rights may easily turn into a nightmare. The article first focuses on the Hungarian constitutional basis of the state of emergency (Section 2). Next, it analyses the text of the constitution with respect to the limitation of fundamental rights and elaborates on the various interpretations through the lens of the case-law of the Constitutional Court (Sections 3-4). Finally, the article concludes that despite the rigid wording of the Hungarian Fundamental Law, constitutional rights can be restricted only if the restriction meets the necessity-proportionality test (Section 5) |
Public Health Emergency: National, European and International Law Responses |
Defining the Common European Way of LifeExploring the Concept of Europeanness |
Journal | Hungarian Yearbook of International Law and European Law, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | European identity, Common European Way of Life, coronavirus, European citizenship, Hungary, enlargement policy, Europeanness |
Authors | Lilla Nóra Kiss and Orsolya Johanna Sziebig |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The article focuses on the interpretation of the European Way of Life and the concept of Europeanness. Ursula von der Leyen determined the Promotion of the European Way of Life as a priority of the 2019-2024 Commission. The purpose behind this was to strengthen European democracy and place the citizens into the center of decision-making. The article examines the role of European identity, European citizenship and those historical-traditional conditions that make our way of life ‘common’. The Common European Way of Life may be defined as a value system based on the established legal basis of EU citizenship that can be grasped in the pursuit of common principles and the exercise of rights guaranteed to all EU citizens, limited only under exceptional circumstances and ensuring socio-economic convergence. The article covers general conceptual issues but also focuses on the extraordinary impact of the COVID-19. Lastly, the relevant aspects of enlargement policy are also explored. |
Article |
|
Journal | Erasmus Law Review, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | text mining, machine learning, law, natural language processing |
Authors | Arthur Dyevre |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Many questions facing legal scholars and practitioners can be answered only by analysing and interrogating large collections of legal documents: statutes, treaties, judicial decisions and law review articles. I survey a range of novel techniques in machine learning and natural language processing – including topic modelling, word embeddings and transfer learning – that can be applied to the large-scale investigation of legal texts |
Article |
|
Journal | Politics of the Low Countries, Issue 2 2021 |
Keywords | COVID-19, crisis-management, democratic compensators, exceptionalism |
Authors | Tom Massart, Thijs Vos, Clara Egger e.a. |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Since January 2020, European countries have implemented a wide range of restrictions to contain the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet governments have also implemented democratic compensators in order to offset the negative impacts of restrictions. This article aims to account for the variation of their use between Belgium, the Netherlands and France. We analyse three drivers: the strength of counterpowers, the ruling parties’ ideological leanings and political support. Building on an original data set, our results distinguish between embedded and ad hoc compensators. We find that ad hoc compensators are championed mainly by counterpowers, but also by ideology of the ruling coalitions in Belgium and the Netherlands and used strategically to maintain political support in France. Evidence on the link between embedded compensators and counterpowers is more ambiguous. |
Article |
Democratic Scrutiny of COVID-19 LawsAre Parliamentary Committees Up to the Job? |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 2 2021 |
Keywords | parliament, scrutiny, committees, COVID-19, rights, legislation, Australia, New Zealand, United Kingdom |
Authors | Sarah Moulds |
AbstractAuthor's information |
In response to the complex and potentially devastating threat posed by COVID-19, parliaments around the world have transferred unprecedented powers to executive governments and their agencies (Edgar, ‘Law-making in a Crisis’, 2020), often with the full support of the communities they represent. These laws were passed within days, sometimes hours, with limited safeguards and a heavy reliance on sunsetting provisions, some of which are dependent on the pandemic being officially called to an end. While parliaments themselves have suspended or reduced sitting days (Twomey, ‘A Virtual Australian Parliament is Possible’, 2020), parliamentary committees have emerged as the forum of choice when it comes to providing some form of parliamentary oversight of executive action. |
Research Note |
Caretaker Cabinets in BelgiumA New Measurement and Typology |
Journal | Politics of the Low Countries, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | caretaker government, Belgium, cabinets, political crisis |
Authors | Régis Dandoy and Lorenzo Terrière |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Belgium is probably the world’s best known case of where caretaker governments reside. Yet a clear scholarly definition and measurement of this concept is missing. Based on a detailed analysis of the Belgian federal cabinets, this research note explores the main characteristics and measures the length of the various caretaker periods. We find that Belgium was governed for no less than 1,485 days by a caretaker government between 2007 and 2020, which equals more than four full calendar years. This research note also presents a novel typology of caretaker periods based on the institutional and political practice within the Belgian legislative and executive branches. This typology can be used to assess caretaker periods at other levels of government as well as in other countries in order to improve our understanding of the many ‘faces’ that a caretaker government can take on. |
Article |
|
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | Seychelles, legislative drafting, drug abuse, drug abuse legislation |
Authors | Amelie Nourrice |
AbstractAuthor's information |
This article was written with the intention of figuring out why the Seychelles has been unable to douse the drug epidemic despite apparent vigorous efforts on the part of the government and of finding a new way of curtailing drug abuse without relying entirely on legislation, which although in some ways are necessary, has on its own, been incapable serving efficacy. |
Article |
Parliamentary Control of Delegated LegislationLessons from a Comparative Study of the UK Parliament and the Korean National Assembly |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | statutory instruments, delegated legislation, parliamentary control, parliamentary scrutiny, Korea |
Authors | Mikang Chae |
AbstractAuthor's information |
As the scale of administrative agencies expands and their functions become more specialized in the complex and variable administrative reality, delegated legislation has increased explosively. This article examines the need for the introduction of appropriate parliamentary controls to prevent harm caused by the flood of delegated legislation. Through comparison with the UK Parliament, this article identifies the relative position of the Korean National Assembly and presents measures to strengthen parliamentary scrutiny on delegated legislation. |
Article |
Reducing Ethnic Conflict in Guyana through Political Reform |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | Guyana, race, ethnic conflict, political power, constitutional reform |
Authors | Nicola Pierre |
AbstractAuthor's information |
This article discusses using constitutional reform to reduce ethnic conflict in Guyana. I start by exploring the determinants of ethnic conflict. I next examine Guyana’s ethnopolitical history to determine what factors led to political alignment on ethnic lines and then evaluate the effect of the existing political institutions on ethnic conflict. I close with a discussion on constitutional reform in which I consider a mix of consociationalist, integrative, and power-constraining mechanisms that may be effective in reducing ethnic conflict in Guyana’s ethnopolitical circumstances. |
Article |
Unwrapping the Effectiveness Test as a Measure of Legislative QualityA Case Study of the Tuvalu Climate Change Resilience Act 2019 |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | effectiveness test, legislative quality, drafting process, Tuvalu Climate Change Resilience Act 2019 |
Authors | Laingane Italeli Talia |
AbstractAuthor's information |
|
Case Reports |
2021/12 Expiry of untaken annual leave and entitlement to compensation (SI) |
Journal | European Employment Law Cases, Issue 1 2021 |
Keywords | Paid Leave |
Authors | Petra Smolnikar and Tjaša Marinček |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Following ECJ case law, the Supreme Court of the Republic of Slovenia has ruled that a worker is entitled to compensation for unused annual leave in the event that the termination of employment has occurred 15 months after the end of the transfer period (i.e. the period for the transfer of the right to use annual leave) provided for in national legislation. The relevant transposition period is therefore three months longer than the transposition period set out in the Slovenian law. |
Article |
Comments and Content from Virtual International Online Dispute Resolution Forum1-2 March 2021, Hosted by the National Center for Technology and Dispute Resolution (NCTDR) |
Journal | International Journal of Online Dispute Resolution, Issue 1 2021 |
Authors | David Allen Larson, Noam Ebner, Jan Martinez e.a. |
Abstract |
For the past 20 years, NCTDR has hosted a series of ODR Forums in locations around the world. For 2021, the Forum was held virtually, with live presentation over a web video platform, and recorded presentations available to participants. A full recording of the sessions can be found through http://odr.info/2021-virtual-odr-forum-now-live/. The following items are narrative notes from some of the presentations: |