This contribution examines the legal legitimacy of ‘Article IV Consultations’ performed by the IMF as part of its responsibility for surveillance under Article IV of its Articles of Agreement. The analysis focuses on tax recommendations given by the Fund to its member countries in the context of Consultations. This paper determines that these tax recommendations derive from a broad interpretation of the powers and obligations that have been agreed to in the Fund’s Articles of Agreement. Such an interpretation leads to a legitimacy deficit, as member countries of the Fund have not given their state consent to receive recommendations as to which should be the tax policies it should adopt. |
Search result: 42 articles
Year 2017 xArticle |
|
Journal | Erasmus Law Review, Issue 2 2017 |
Keywords | legitimacy, International Monetary Fund (IMF), Article IV Consultations, tax recommendations, global tax governance |
Authors | Sophia Murillo López |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Article |
|
Journal | Erasmus Law Review, Issue 2 2017 |
Keywords | base erosion and profit shifting, OECD, G20, legitimacy, international tax reform |
Authors | Sissie Fung |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The global financial crisis of 2008 and the following public uproar over offshore tax evasion and corporate aggressive tax planning scandals gave rise to unprecedented international cooperation on tax information exchange and coordination on corporate tax reforms. At the behest of the G20, the OECD developed a comprehensive package of ‘consensus-based’ policy reform measures aimed to curb base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) by multinationals and to restore fairness and coherence to the international tax system. The legitimacy of the OECD/G20 BEPS Project, however, has been widely challenged. This paper explores the validity of the legitimacy concerns raised by the various stakeholders regarding the OECD/G20 BEPS Project. |
Article |
|
Journal | Erasmus Law Review, Issue 2 2017 |
Keywords | World Bank, legality, legitimacy, global tax governance, tax policy and tax administration reforms |
Authors | Uyanga Berkel-Dorlig |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The emergence of global tax governance was triggered by common tax problems, which are now still being faced by international society of nation-states. In the creation of this framework, international institutions have been playing a major role. One of these institutions is the World Bank (Bank). However, those who write about the virtues and vices of the main creators of the framework usually disregard the Bank. This article, therefore, argues that this disregard is not justified because the Bank has also been playing a prominent role. Since two informal decisions taken in the past have contributed to this position of the Bank, the article gives in addition to it answers to the following two related questions: whether these informal decisions of the Bank were legal and if so, what implications, if any, they have for the Bank’s legitimacy. |
Article |
Codification in a Civil Law Jurisdiction: An Italian Perspective |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 4 2017 |
Keywords | civil law jurisdictions, codification, consolidation, legislative drafting, judicial review |
Authors | Enrico Albanesi |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The aim of this article is to describe the mechanism of codification in a civil law jurisdiction. The case study will be based on the Italian system. The history and developments of the Italian codification will also be described here. |
Article |
Codification in a Civil Law Jurisdiction: A Northern European Perspective |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 4 2017 |
Keywords | codification, types, civil law, legal certainty, ICT |
Authors | Patricia Popelier |
AbstractAuthor's information |
In western civil law jurisdictions, 19th century large-scale codification projects have made way for more specific, technical operations. While several terms for various operations are used – from coordination to consolidation or recasting – they all serve to compile normative texts within one single document for the sake of clarity and legal certainty. A more fundamental distinction can be made between formal and substantial codifications, the one more technical, the other large and fundamental. Substantial law reforms are problematized in this era of multilevel governance and digitalization. Nowadays, substantial codifications are essentially non-exhaustive, inconsistent, and fragmentized. Also, they rely upon formal consolidations, and generate new formal consolidations. While formal consolidations are still treated as logistic projects, more developed ICT tools may enable their transformation into continuous processes. |
Editorial |
|
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 4 2017 |
Authors | Jonathan Teasdale |
Author's information |
Article |
Time for a Code: Reform of Sentencing Law in England and Wales |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 4 2017 |
Keywords | Law Commission, codification, consolidation, consultation, criminal procedure |
Authors | Harry O’Sullivan and David Ormerod |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The Law Commission of England and Wales is currently working to produce a New Sentencing Code that will seek to remedy problems with one of the most heavily used and unsatisfactory areas of statutory law. It responds to the problems of complexity and inaccessibility in the current sentencing legislation, and more fundamentally in the process by which sentencing legislation is created and implemented. The aim is to introduce the new Code as a consolidation Bill in 2018 with a view to it being in force from early 2019. This article provides an overview of the problems endemic to the current law and how the Commission envisages that the new Sentencing Code will provide not only a remedy, but a lasting one. |
Article |
The Reform and Harmonization of Commercial Laws in the East African Community |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 4 2017 |
Keywords | law reform, harmonization of laws, commercial laws, legal transplants, East African Community |
Authors | Agasha Mugasha |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The partner states in the East African Community (EAC) have modernized their commercial laws to claim their post-colonial identity and facilitate development. While law reform and the harmonization of laws are both methods of shaping laws, the national law reform programmes in the EAC mainly aim to ensure that the laws reflect the domestic socioeconomic circumstances, in contrast to the harmonization of national commercial laws, which focuses on the attainment of economic development. This article observes that the reformed and harmonized commercial laws in the EAC are mainly legal transplants of the principles of transnational commercial law that have been adapted to meet domestic needs and aspirations. |
Article |
|
Journal | Erasmus Law Review, Issue 3 2017 |
Keywords | same-sex marriage, gay marriage, European consensus, margin of appreciation, consensus-based analysis by the ECtHR |
Authors | Masuma Shahid |
AbstractAuthor's information |
This contribution assesses the consensus-based analysis and reasoning of the European Court of Human Rights in recent judgments concerning equal marriage rights and compares it to the Court’s past jurisprudence on European consensus and the margin of appreciation awarded to Member States regarding the issue of equal marriage rights. The contribution aims to analyse whether there is a parallel to be seen between the rapid global trend of legalisation of same-sex marriage and the development or evolution of the case law of the ECtHR on the same topic. Furthermore, it demonstrates that the Court’s consensus-based analysis is problematic for several reasons and provides possible alternative approaches to the balancing of the Court between, on the one hand, protecting rights of minorities (in this case same-sex couples invoking equal marriage rights) under the European Convention on Human Rights and, on the other hand, maintaining its credibility, authority and legitimacy towards Member States that might disapprove of the evolving case law in the context of same-sex relationships. It also offers insights as to the future of European consensus in the context of equal marriage rights and ends with some concluding remarks. |
Article |
|
Journal | Erasmus Law Review, Issue 3 2017 |
Keywords | access to justice, procedural law, courts, civil justice reform, comparative law |
Authors | Catherine Piché |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Canada has a complex system of courts that seek to serve Canadians in view of the traditional objectives of civil justice – principally accessibility, efficiency, fairness, efficacy, proportionality and equality. The Canadian court system is generally considered by its users to work well and to have legitimacy. Yet, researchers have found that ‘there is a tendency for people involved in a civil case to become disillusioned about the ability of the system to effect a fair and timely resolution to a civil justice problem’. This article will discuss the ways in which reforms of procedural law and civil justice have originated and continue to be made throughout Canada, both nationally and provincially, as well as the trends and influences in making these reforms. With hundreds of contemporary procedural reforms having been discussed, proposed and/or completed since the first days of Canadian colonisation on a national basis and in the Canadian provinces and territory, providing a detailed analysis will prove challenging. This article will nonetheless provide a review of civil justice and procedural reform issues in Canada, focusing principally, at the provincial level, on the systems of Ontario and Quebec. Importantly, I will seek to reconcile the increasing willingness to have an economically efficient civil justice and the increased power of judges in managing cases, with our court system’s invasion of ADR and its prioritisation of informal modes of adjudication. |
Article |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2017 |
Keywords | Sincerity of emotions, Guilt, Feelings, Apology, Offender |
Authors | Margreet Luth-Morgan |
AbstractAuthor's information |
This paper discusses the meaning and the importance of emotions, in particular the sincere guilt feelings of the offender. It is argued that the emotion of guilt reveals important information about the offender’s values and normative position. In the remainder of the paper, special consideration is awarded to the argument concerning ritual apologies, which might contain value even when insincere. This argument is rejected, on two grounds: 1. if the apology ritual does not aim for sincere guilt feelings, then the use of the symbol of apology is not fitting; and 2. if the apology ritual does aim for sincere guilt, then an insincere apology devalues the sincere expression. |
Article |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2017 |
Keywords | Klaas Rozemond, Ronald M. Dworkin, Legality in criminal law, Rights conception of the rule of law, Legal certainty |
Authors | Briain Jansen |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The extensive interpretation of criminal law to the detriment of the defendant in criminal law is often problematized in doctrinal theory. Extensive interpretation is then argued to be problematic in the light of important ideals such as democracy and legal certainty in criminal law. In the Dutch discussion of this issue, Klaas Rozemond has argued that sometimes extensive interpretation is mandated by the rule of law in order to protect the rights of victims. Rozemond grounds his argument on a reading of Dworkin’s distinction between the rule-book and the rights conception of the rule of law. In this article, I argue that Dworkin’s rights conception, properly considered, does not necessarily mandate the imposition of criminal law or its extensive interpretation in court in order to protect victims’ rights. |
Article |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2017 |
Keywords | empirical legal studies, apologies, procedural justice, humiliation, victim rights |
Authors | Vincent Geeraets and Wouter Veraart |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The central question in this article is whether an empirical-legal approach of victimhood and victim rights could offer a sufficient basis for proposals of legal reform of the legal system. In this article, we choose a normative-critical approach and raise some objections to the way in which part of such research is currently taking place in the Netherlands, on the basis of two examples of research in this field, one dealing with compelled apologies as a possible remedy within civil procedural law and the other with the victim’s right to be heard within the criminal legal procedure. In both cases, we argue, the strong focus on the measurable needs of victims can lead to a relatively instrumental view of the legal system. The legal system must then increasingly be tailored to the wishes and needs of victims. Within this legal-empirical, victim-oriented approach, there is little regard for the general normative principles of our present legal system, in which an equal and respectful treatment of each human being as a free and responsible legal subject is a central value. We argue that results of empirical-legal research should not too easily or too quickly be translated into proposals for legal reform, but first become part of a hermeneutical discussion about norms and legal principles, specific to the normative quality of legal science itself. |
Article |
The New World Order in Dispute ResolutionBrexit and the Trump Presidency |
Journal | International Journal of Online Dispute Resolution, Issue 1 2017 |
Keywords | dispute resolution, Brexit, Donald Trump, technology, trade |
Authors | Ijeoma Ononogbu |
AbstractAuthor's information |
The Brexit vote and Donald J Trump as the leader of the Free world in 2016 brought in a new world order. Two hugely important and unexpected events of 2016. Both have called into question the stability of established international commercial dispute resolution schemes in the United Kingdom and the United States in our tech savvy world. As the impact of both events unfolds, adaptations made to the existing dispute resolution schemes will be negotiated and the role that technology can play in the new approaches to international commercial dispute resolution will be determined. Consequently, there has been the changing face of Western politics after the Cold War, based on traditional group identity giving way to an uncertain landscape in which the political class struggle to define. The impact and disruption of technology in politics has given everyone a voice regardless of social class. Consequently, the EU under Mr Juncker and the UK Prime Minister seem to have mutual respect in their negotiations, given that the UK has made a number of notable concessions in order to move the trade discussions forward. |
Conference Paper |
ODR and Third Party Injury Claims Processing |
Journal | International Journal of Online Dispute Resolution, Issue 2 2017 |
Authors | Stewart McCulloch |
Author's information |
Conference Paper |
Conference Opening Remarks |
Journal | International Journal of Online Dispute Resolution, Issue 2 2017 |
Keywords | Online Dispute Resolution, online court, access to justice, technology and the law |
Authors | Lord Justice Briggs |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Lord Justice Briggs has been intimately involved in the development of technology for improving access to justice in the UK. He was the author of a report that energized the move toward online dispute resolution in the courts. These remarks are a retrospective look at his work, now that he is a member of the UK Supreme Court, and no longer involved day-to-day in ODR development. |
Conference Paper |
Recent ODR Developments in China |
Journal | International Journal of Online Dispute Resolution, Issue 2 2017 |
Authors | FANG Xuhui |
Author's information |
Article |
Intersecting ProfessionsA Public Health Perspective on Law to Address Health Care Conflicts |
Journal | International Journal of Conflict Engagement and Resolution, Issue 1 2017 |
Keywords | public health, Alternative Dispute Resolution, public law, health promotion |
Authors | Michal Alberstein and Nadav Davidovitch PhD |
AbstractAuthor's information |
This paper examines the intersection between the two professions – law and medicine – with reference to systematic transformations that have characterized their development in the past century. In particular, the paper examines the co-emergence of the new public health and health promotion scholarship along with the development of the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) movement in the second half of the 20th century. The two movements, with their later developments, have aspired to change the focus of professionals in the field, and both have been tremendously successful on the one hand, and on the other have remained marginal to mainstream training and identity building of contemporary lawyers and doctors. |
Editorial |
Foreword |
Journal | International Journal of Conflict Engagement and Resolution, Issue 1 2017 |
Authors | Michal Alberstein, Nadav Davidovitch PHD and Shelly Kamin-Friedman |
Author's information |
Article |
French Constitution, Droit Administratif and the Civil Code |
Journal | European Journal of Law Reform, Issue 3 2017 |
Keywords | Droit Administratif, Civil Code, Conseil d’État, public order |
Authors | Zia Akhtar |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Droit Administratif in France is a separate branch of law that exists in parallel to the civil and criminal law. The law has been developed from the concept of separation of powers that is ingrained in the French constitution. Its concepts derive from the Code civil that is implemented in France since its inception in the Napoleonic era and this has undergone reform that has made the role of the judges more interventionist. The highest administrative court is the Conseil d’État, which is at the apex of the machinery of administrative courts that are an important part of public law’s discourse and there is a hierarchy of courts that consider appeals and regulate the norms of conduct of state officials towards the citizens. The judges receive induction and training before taking on the role of occupation and that has been inculcated in the French administrative court judges. This article looks at the separate system of administrative law and its success in preserving the necessary checks and balances in the constitution, which it is intended to protect. This is an examination of the developing concept of French justice, the doctrine of separation of powers and civil procedural changes that enable the grievance of citizens against officials to be heard more expeditiously. |